LGBT+ life is becoming easier in Japan, but not compared to its competitors
"Japan's LGBT+ progress outpaces politics"
Written by: Rurika Imahashi, Nikkei Asian Review - October 15, 2019
Nolan Matcovich - October 22, 2019
This article focuses on how, in a number of ways, Japan's progress on LGBT rights issues in recent years has been led much more extensively by municipalities, courts, companies, and ministries, while the national and most prefectural governments have done little to introduce bills or implement laws about LGBT rights issues, such as marriage equality and anti-discrimination measures. After featuring stories from this past year about unofficial recognition of LGBT relationships being used by ministries and local governments as grounds for halting deportation orders and issuing residency permits, among other things, the article can be split into three main parts. First, the author details the increasing trend of recognition of same-sex unions in municipalities (and one prefecture) across Japan, sparked by Shibuya's move to do so four years ago. Second, she discusses the effects of a lack of a national recognition of same-sex marriages or unions on business in Japan, and lastly, she talks about the Abe government's stance on same-sex marriage legislations and tactics, namely those based around the constitution, that many opposition politicians have accused him and his party of using to stall the political discussion on legalizing same-sex marriage.
Most surprisingly for me, however, was the issue of the current state of LGBT rights in Japan's effects on the business community here. One of the main talking points was that due to its shrinking and aging population, Japan needs to compete with countries in Europe, North America, and Oceania to attract foreign skilled workers to its companies. However, with a lack of same-sex marriage recognition and other laws that prohibit anti-LGBT discrimination and would help normalize LGBT culture in Japanese society, Japan does not fare well in this competition when it comes to attracting foreign skilled workers from the LGBT community. Japan is the only member of the G7 and one of a small handful of members of the OECD that does not formally recognize same-sex relationships. The article describes the situation of Moriaki Kida, regional chief operating officer consultancy EY Japan, who "laments that several of his colleagues have left Japan because it does not offer legal protection for their same-sex partners or their children." Kida has had much more personal experiences with that same lack of legal protections for LGBT couples, when he and his husband, a British citizen, moved from the US three years ago. His husband, not eligible for a spouse visa which would have allowed him to work, instead had to forfeit employment and take Japanese language classes to qualify for a long-term student visa.
This is an issue that I had previously thought about from almost all of its angles, but realized while reading this article that I had never actually thought of the issue as a whole in this way, despite its very real applications to my own life. For the past fourteen years, Japanese language and culture have been an immense part of my life, and as someone who loves traveling and spending time abroad, including in Japan, whether or not I am considering moving to Japan has been a question I have gotten quite often. For the past eight years, I have identified as gay. Over the last couple of years, when people has asked me about moving to Japan, my answers have ranged anywhere from an ever-shrinking time period to a flat out "no, not really."
There is a much wider range of reasons as to why I am hesitant to move to Japan long-term, but reading this article, I realized that Kida's and other people's experiences concisely combine many of those reasons. Moving here, I would be less likely to face public discrimination than I would be in most countries in Africa, the Middle East, or Central Asia, but it's still not great, especially compared to my other options of staying in the US or moving to Canada or Europe. And having to worry about whether or not my husband or partner and I would be able to receive the same benefits of government recognition certainly doesn't help that. In many senses, I am one of these "skilled workers" Japan would want to attract but, unless quite a bit changes, almost certainly won't. While it is encouraging to see Japanese society and local governments moving forward on acceptance of the LGBT community, at the end of the day, the national government is what must make considerable changes for people in my position to want to settle here.